Exploring what sinister stories reveal about the rest of us.
Pretty Evil explores the psychological forces behind destructive human behavior — from charismatic predators and cult leaders to institutional failures, social influence, moral panic, and the hidden mechanisms that allow harm to flourish.

Fraternity Hazing: Dying to Belong
Stone Foltz, Timothy Piazza, Michael Deng and George Desdunes died in cases involving fraternity hazing, each under very different circumstances. What connects them is a harder question: what happens to our sense of right and wrong when belonging, tradition and group loyalty make dangerous behavior feel normal?
Play Episode (69 mins)The crime is only the beginning of the story.
Through immersive storytelling and psychological analysis, Pretty Evil explores what these cases reveal about power, vulnerability, identity, persuasion, and the darker parts of human nature.
“What we find most unsettling is not the exceptional cruelty of the predator, but the predictable complicity of the crowd.”
Critical Inquiry
We look past sensational details to chart systemic vulnerabilities and diagnostic frameworks.
Human Mechanisms
An analytical lens on conformity, and the social architecture that lets harm hide in plain sight.
Browse by Category
Pretty Evil
The show's core category, focusing on danger in disguise.
Explore Category 02Portrait of a Predator
Behavioral and cultural dissections of dangerous people.
Explore Category 03Under Observation
Experiments, research, and unsettling things behavioral science has revealed about ordinary people.
Explore Category 04Failure by Design
How system loops, bad incentives, and coverups build modern tragedies.
Explore Category 05Hive Mind
Social contagion, mob mechanics, and how moral panic overrides logic.
Explore Category 06Side Notes
Shorter, more casual Pretty Evil episodes focused on a specific question, developing case, recent crime story, or piece of true-crime conventional wisdom.
Explore Category 07Psychological Autopsy
Looking back at a crime to reconstruct the relationships, warning signs, and stories surrounding it.
Explore CategoryQuestions About the Show
What is Pretty Evil?
Pretty Evil is a psychology-driven true crime podcast that explores the psychological forces behind destructive human behavior — from charismatic predators and cult leaders to institutional failures, social influence, and the hidden mechanisms that allow harm to flourish.
Who hosts Pretty Evil?
Pretty Evil is created, written, and hosted by Jessica Strohm. Her husband Matt co-hosts Pretty Evil After Dark, the show's companion aftershow.
Where can I listen to Pretty Evil?
Pretty Evil is available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and every other major podcast platform.
What topics does Pretty Evil cover?
Episodes are organized into six recurring categories — Pretty Evil, Portrait of a Predator, Under Observation, Failure by Design, Hive Mind, and Side Notes — covering everything from charismatic predators to institutional failures, psychological experiments, and moral panics.
Is Pretty Evil independent and commercial-free?
Yes. Pretty Evil is fully independent and commercial-free, funded directly by listener support rather than advertising.
How can I support Pretty Evil?
You can support the show through a Patreon membership, a one-time donation, or simply by rating, reviewing, and sharing the podcast with others.
Come for the crime. Stay for the existential crisis.
Join the email list for research notes, reading lists, and updates on newly launched episodes.












